hoa board make a decision by email

Can An HOA Board Make A Decision By Email?

Can an HOA board make a decision by email? While email makes communication among board members faster and more convenient, it should not be used to pass policies or resolutions. There are certain legal concerns that can arise when boards make decisions outside of formal meetings.

 

Can an HOA Board Make a Decision by Email?

In general, an HOA board can’t make a decision by email, but state laws and the association’s governing documents may say otherwise.

 

Associations are typically bound by open meeting requirements. This means that board members must make decisions transparently, giving owners a chance to witness the process at an open meeting.

 

Can a Condo Board Make a Decision by Email in Illinois?

Under 765 ILCS 605/18 of the Illinois Condominium Property Act, condo associations must generally conduct business and vote at open meetings. Condo boards can’t make decisions by email.

 

Additionally, the board must provide unit owners with at least 48 hours’ notice of a meeting. These requirements give owners an opportunity to observe how the board reaches decisions that affect the community.

 

Can an HOA Board Make a Decision by Email in Illinois?

Under 765 ILCS 160/1-40 of the Illinois Common Interest Community Association Act, HOA boards must hold open meetings. When conducting official votes, the board must allow owners to observe the process.

 

The goal is the same. Associations generally can’t make decisions by email, as it shuts out owners and diminishes transparency.

 

Can HOA Board Members Communicate by Email?

hoa board decisions by email
While HOA board voting by email is generally prohibited, using email as a communication tool is allowed.

 

Email can be a convenient communication tool, especially for busy board members. It can also be quite helpful for distributing information to all residents. That said, there’s a difference between sending updates and conducting official business.

 

What are the Acceptable Uses of Email in an HOA?

Depending on what the bylaws allow, an association can generally use email to schedule board meetings, distribute meeting agendas, share financial reports, send reminders, and communicate previously approved decisions. Boards must remain within the bounds of their authority.

 

What are the Improper Uses of Email in an HOA?

In general, an association should not use email to vote on vendor contracts, approve expenditures, debate proposed rules, conduct informal meetings, or make decisions that otherwise require an open meeting. Improper use can invalidate decisions and resolutions, not to mention call the board’s credibility into question.

 

Are There Exceptions to the Rule Against HOA Board Email Voting?

While an HOA board generally shouldn’t use email to make decisions, an emergency situation is an exception to this rule.

 

Under 765 ILCS 605/18, condo boards may make decisions during emergencies without following open meeting requirements. The statute strictly defines an emergency as anything that poses an urgent threat or danger to the structural integrity of common elements or to the owners’ life, property, health, or safety.

 

The law allows a condo board to formally ratify and confirm the emergency actions after the fact. Following the emergency event, the board must notify owners of the emergency within 7 business days. Additionally, it must give a general description of what actions it took to address the emergency within 7 business days as well.

 

Can an HOA Board Make Decisions in Executive Sessions?

While association boards can discuss certain matters in private, Illinois law generally prohibits them from making decisions in executive sessions. The final votes must still take place during the open portion of the board meeting.

 

Can an HOA Board Ratify Email Decisions at the Next Meeting?

If an HOA board improperly made a decision by email, it can’t simply ratify that decision as a way to remedy the procedural breach.

 

Ratification is the process of formally confirming an action or decision that someone has already taken or made. In this case, it’s the board.

 

Under Illinois law, both HOAs and condo associations must take a vote at an open meeting. Boards can’t reach a decision using email. While emergency situations allow for ratification, normal operational decisions are a different matter.

 

Of course, nobody is perfect. If the board mistakenly made a decision outside of an open meeting, it should immediately contact its attorney or community manager for legal guidance.

 

Can an HOA Board Vote Electronically Instead?

hoa board voting by email
Electronic voting is possible, but board members must distinguish between email voting and voting during an electronic meeting. Those are not the same.

 

Under 765 ILCS 605/18 of the Condominium Property Act, board members can participate in meetings by technology, such as video or telephone conference. That said, the method must allow all participants to communicate with each other. Additionally, 765 ILCS 605/18.8 permits the use of technology for voting.

 

Still, associations must meet the same notice and open meeting requirements. Owners must still be able to attend the meeting.

 

What Happens if an HOA Board Makes Decisions by Email?

When leaders make HOA board decisions by email, consequences can follow, including potential legal challenges, invalidation of decisions, breach of fiduciary duty, loss of homeowner trust, and even litigation.

 

  • Potential Legal Challenges. Owners may challenge board decisions, possibly delaying implementation.
  • Invalidation of Decisions. Improperly made decisions can be rendered null and void.
  • Breach of Fiduciary Duty. Boards have legal obligations to fulfill, and making decisions by email may lead to breach claims.
  • Loss of Homeowner Trust. Owners are more likely to question the board’s actions and decisions when it fails to follow proper procedure.
  • Litigation. In some cases, the association can even face litigation, which can be costly and time-consuming.

 

How Can HOA Boards Make Decisions Between Meetings?

There are several ways to make timely decisions without violating the law, such as scheduling special meetings, conducting proper virtual meetings, increasing the frequency of regular board meetings, establishing legal emergency procedures, and adopting clear email guidelines.

 

1. Schedule Special Board Meetings

The board doesn’t always have to wait until the next meeting to address association business. Both Illinois condominium and HOA laws allow the board president or 25% of board members to call special board meetings. Notice requirements still apply.

 

2. Conduct Properly Noticed Virtual Meetings

Virtual meetings make it easier for board members to attend without traveling to a physical location. They also give owners a convenient way to observe board proceedings.

 

3. Increase the Frequency of Regular Board Meetings

If association business constantly comes up, the board may find it wiser to schedule regular board meetings more often. This way, there’s less downtime in between meetings.

 

4. Establish Legal Emergency Procedures

The board should develop clear procedures for responding to emergencies. These procedures should address emergency spending, reporting, owner notification, and ratification.

 

5. Adopt Clear Email Guidelines

The board should establish guidelines for the proper use of email. These can help the board avoid violations, even unintentionally.

 

Can an HOA Board Make a Decision by Email? Answered!

Association boards must conduct votes and make decisions at a properly noticed open meeting. While acceptable as a general form of communication, email should not be used to perform official business.

 

Finding the right management partner can make a world of difference to your community. Associations in Chicago and beyond can rely on First Community Management for expert HOA and condo management services. Call us today at (312) 829 8900 or contact us online to get started!

 

RELATED ARTICLES: