Serving an association means fulfilling the fiduciary duties of HOA board members. These duties should not be taken lightly, as a single violation can come with legal consequences. Those currently serving on the board or are planning to run for an elected position must understand what these duties are.
What are the Fiduciary Duties of HOA Board Members?
Board membership comes with a host of responsibilities and legal obligations. Per the Illinois Common Interest Community Act and the Condominium Property Act, board members owe a fiduciary duty to the association and its residents.
Here are the fiduciary duties of HOA board members.
1. Duty of Care
The first fiduciary responsibility of HOA board members is the duty of care. This refers to the board members’ responsibility to thoroughly investigate issues. It also covers the obligation to perform due diligence whenever soliciting a vendor for work or making plans for property improvements.
2. Duty of Loyalty
The second HOA board of directors fiduciary responsibility is the duty of loyalty. This means not taking action that could jeopardize the community. Board members can’t put their personal interests first.
Disclosing potential conflicts of interest falls under this duty. If a board member stands to financially gain from hiring a vendor or personally benefit from a rule change, they must inform all other directors. In some cases, they must even recuse themselves from the discussion and vote to keep everything impartial.
3. Duty to Make Decisions in the Best Interest of the Community
The final HOA board member fiduciary duty is the duty to prioritize the best interest of the community. This means that community interests come before individual interests. If a decision will benefit only a few homeowners and put everyone else at a disadvantage, the board must not approve it.
Other Legal Obligations
Apart from the above HOA board fiduciary duty, directors must fulfill other legal responsibilities. This includes abiding by the governing documents of the association. Additionally, boards must hold at least four board meetings and one annual meeting every year.
Other management duties include:
- Maintaining an annual budget
- Providing for the ongoing operation, care, and maintenance of the common elements
- Ensuring adequate insurance coverage
- Levying, collecting and expending dues and assessments
- Enforcing the rules in a fair and consistent manner
- Sharing financial records and other pertinent documents with owners
- Selecting and managing vendors using a fair and standard process
- Budgeting and maintaining reserves
- Facilitating fair elections
- Complying with federal, state, and local laws
Understanding the Business Judgment Rule
The Business Judgment Rule protects the association’s board members from liability, but only to a certain extent. It applies to honest mistakes or unsuccessful decisions that otherwise followed the board’s fiduciary duties. If the board acted in good faith, with reasonable care, and within the scope of their authority, this rule can offer liability protection.
How to Uphold HOA Board Fiduciary Duty
An HOA board breach of fiduciary duty can come with several unsavory consequences. Fortunately, there are some strategies the board can adopt to ensure compliance.
1. Adhere to State Laws and the Governing Documents
Associations must follow state laws and the governing documents at all times. Breaching these regulations can count a breach of fiduciary duty.
2. Communicate Openly and Transparently
Transparency is paramount in any community. The board should keep owners in the loop and make records available for inspection. Additionally, board members should keep an open line of communication with their fellow directors, vendors, and other third parties.
3. Manage Finances With Integrity
Boards must maintain accurate and transparent records of the association’s finances. It also helps to adopt internal controls to prevent fraud and misuse of funds. If something seems suspicious, the board must investigate thoroughly.
4. Address Issues Immediately
If an owner raises a concern, the board should acknowledge and investigate it as soon as possible. Delays can diminish the owners’ trust in the board.
5. Enforce Consistently
Boards must enforce the rules in a fair and equal manner. There is no room for favoritism, bias, or any other personal feelings when it comes to rule enforcement. Boards must implement a standard procedure, including notice and an opportunity to be heard.
6. Rely on Facts
Boards should make decisions using sound logic and factual evidence. They should never let gossip, rumors, or unreasonable opinions cloud their judgment.
7. Avoid Conflicts of Interest
Board members must never personally gain from a decision or action. If there is a potential conflict of interest, disclose and recuse. Even the mere appearance of a conflict of interest can call the board’s credibility into question.
8. Get Professional Advice
Experienced as they may be, board members may need outside help every now and then. Lawyers and HOA management companies can provide valuable insights and recommendations that will help the board fulfill its fiduciary duties.
What Happens When There is a Breach?
Violations of the fiduciary duty of the HOA board of directors come with potential consequences. Depending on the type of breach, effects can include:
1. Loss of Trust
Homeowners easily lose their trust in a board that consistently fails to act in good faith, with reasonable care, or prioritize the community’s best interest. When trust vanishes, owners are more likely to question every board decision.
2. Board Recall
Directors may lose their seats on the board for failing to fulfill their fiduciary duties. When owners are dissatisfied, they can petition for a special meeting with the express purpose of removing the board.
3. Legal Action
Owners can sue HOA for breach of fiduciary duty. The association itself may be named in the lawsuit, but board members can also be found personally liable. Of course, certain protections are in place for boards, such as the Business Judgment Rule and D&O insurance. Yet, if the board committed fraud or intentional misconduct, these protections may not apply.
Satisfying the Fiduciary Duties of HOA Board Members
Board members must carry several responsibilities, both in management and in the legal sense. Understanding these responsibilities will help keep them on the right track and avoid potential breaches. When in doubt, it helps to consult a lawyer or an HOA management company.
First Community Management provides expert HOA, condo, and co-op management services to communities in Chicago. Call us today at (312) 829 8900 or contact us online to learn more!
RELATED ARTICLES:
- The Key Responsibilities Of Condo And HOA Boards
- How Managers Can Help Onboard HOA Board Members
- What Are The Requirements For HOA Board Members?